Paper Workshop CHI19

Next paper workshop: Wednesday, July 11th, 11:00AM; Room H20

!New! What is expected for this workshop:

Progress from last time (identified problems-> fixed)
An additional section of the paper (ideally Related Work, but it can be the section experimental design)

WHAT IS IT?

It is an efficient way to collect feedback from your colleagues about your project
It is an external motivation for writing the important parts of your paper
It significantly accelerate the writing process and the quality of the paper
It provides a global awareness of what your colleagues are doing.
This exercise is used in many (excellent) research groups around the world

Authors:

Authors have to write some parts of the paper. We usually focus on the title, the abstract, the keywords and the introduction of the paper (and the figure 1 if it is relevant), but it might be the experimental design section, related work, etc.
Indicate explicitly which part of the paper should be reviewed.
Better is the writing, better will be the feedback
!New! Use the template of the conference: https://www.acm.org/publications/proceedings-template

Reviewers:

At this stage (June), you should review all papers. When the deadline is approaching (September), and papers have more content, we assign ~3 reviewers per paper.
You should NOT spend more than 15 minutes on each paper.
You should focus on high-level comments such as “I do not understand that and that”, “what is the problem you address”, “what is the contribution”, “Where is the difficulty”, etc.
You should NOT focus on typos and grammar issues.
Be constructive

Authors should submit the papers:
- 24h before the paper workshop on the HCI mailing list.
- Use Pdf format
- The name of the file is paperId_authorName.pdf
You have 24 hours to review the papers
During the group meeting, we provide feedback (~1h00)